I followed the recipe for making it a thicker dip and not the dressing by leaving out the soy milk and vinegar. It should have said decrease the salt also because 1/4 tsp. salt is way too much for the dip. Duh, I should have figured that out for myself but didn't. I added a tsp. of vanilla coconut creamer to sweeten it a little. Sorry, this ranch recipe lost. The winner so far is Veganize This! Ranch Dressing .